Top 8 Root Cause Analysis Tools for Problem-solving

From the intuitive Fishbone Diagram to the probing Pareto Analysis, these tools provide a systematic approach to problem-solving. In this blog, we’ll take you through the top tools that can help you not just solve problems but prevent them from coming back.

Table of Contents

1) Fishbone Diagram

2) Pareto Analysis

3) Fault Tree Analysis

4) Scatter Diagram

5) DMAIC Template

6) 8D Report Template Checklist

7) What are the Five Ps of Root Cause Analysis?

8) What is the Common Tool Used During Root Cause Analysis?

9) Conclusion

1) Fishbone Diagram

One way to understand a problem is to draw it out. Visualising the information can help identify cause-and-effect relationships. A Fishbone Diagram, also known as a cause-and-effect or Ishikawa diagram, organises potential causes into categories, each branching out into more specific factors. This approach is especially useful when exploring concepts like Causal Analysis vs. Root Cause Analysis to uncover underlying issues.

For example, the main problem is at the "head" of the fish. The causes are the "bones" branching from the main line. Here’s a simple breakdown of the steps:

a) Define the Problem: Clearly state the issue at the head of the fish.

b) Identify the Major Cause Categories: Label the main “bones” with broad categories that include people, methods, machines, materials, measurements, and environment.

c) Add Sub-causes: Create smaller branches from each category to dig deeper into specific causes, like training issues or equipment malfunctions.

d) Analyse Relationships: Look for connections between the causes to uncover underlying problems.

2) Pareto Analysis

Pareto Analysis is a critical technique within Root Cause Analysis (RCA), which helps pinpoint the main contributors to a problem. It's rooted in the Pareto Principle, often referred to as the 80/20 rule, suggesting that approximately 80% of problems arise from 20% of the causes.

When using Pareto Analysis in Root Cause Analysis (RCA), the process starts by collecting data on the potential causes of a problem, such as defects or errors in a process. The steps include:

a) Identify Causes: List all possible causes that may be contributing to the issue.

b) Gather Data: Measure how often each cause occurs or its level of impact.

c) Build a Pareto Chart: Arrange the causes on a chart from the most to the least significant.

d) Add a Cumulative Line: Include a cumulative line to show the total impact of the causes together.

e) Focus on Key Causes: Pinpoint the "vital few" causes that have the most considerable impact and prioritise them.

Take the first step in mastering IT Service Management with our ITIL® 4 Foundation Certification Course– join us now!

3) Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)

FTA is a method of finding the causes of problems. It uses a top-down approach to trace failures back to their root causes. It works by creating a tree-like diagram that shows different possible reasons for a failure.

Here’s a simple breakdown of the steps in Fault Tree Analysis:

a) Define the Problem: Clearly outline the failure or issue you’re investigating.

b) Identify the Top Event: Determine the main failure or undesired outcome that you are analysing.

c) Break Down Causes: Trace the causes leading to the top event, identifying potential contributors at each level.

d) Create the Tree Diagram: Use logical gates to map the relationships between events and their causes.

e) Analyse the Tree: Identify the most likely or critical causes that lead to the top event.

f) Take Action: Apply the insights to implement corrective actions and prevent future issues.

Get in-depth knowledge of the responsibilities of an IT Service Manager with our Certified IT Service Manager CITSM Course.

4) Scatter Diagram

A Scatter Diagram, or Scatter Plot, is one of the widely used Root Cause Analysis Tools. It is used to investigate and understand the potential relationship between two variables. It helps RCA by providing the following:

Here’s how you can use it:

a) Plot the Data: Start by mapping the data points on a graph, with each axis representing one of the variables.

b) Look for Trends: Analyse the chart for any noticeable patterns or trends that suggest a relationship between the two variables.

c) Identify Correlations: Check if there is a positive, negative, or no correlation between the variables.

d) Spot Outliers: Highlight any outliers in the data, as they could point to unusual factors influencing the results.

e) Explore Cause-and-Effect:Use the diagram to hypothesise how one variable might affect the other.

f) Compare Data Sets: You can also compare different data sets to see how patterns or correlations vary.

Take your first step towards becoming an ITIL expert. Join our ITIL Foundation today!

5) DMAIC Template

The DMAIC template is a highly structured approach that provides a framework for processing and tackling the problems arising in multiple processes. Every letter of the acronym refers to a different step in problem-solving procedure. They are as follows:

D- Define

Define is the first step in DMAIC. In this stage, team members identify and articulate a specific problem or goal. The purpose here is to set a clear understanding of the issue so that the team may focus on it.

M- Measure

This phase focuses on tracking or measuring the problem using specific metrics. It’s normal to use tools like Pareto charts on a project to pinpoint important areas that need attention. It helps to track progress over time.

A- Analyse

Analysing is the next step. You can break down the possible causes of problems that you are dealing with using Root Rause Analysis. This can help prevent the issue from happening again in the future. Sometimes, the root causes are unknown. In those cases, it is important to list and prioritise the potential causes so as to tackle them efficiently.

I- Improve

This stage aims at examining the performance improvements that could be used to eliminate some of the root causes of issues. During this stage, all improvements should lead to positive changes. Otherwise, they should be reconsidered or replaced with more suitable solutions.

C- Control

Control is an approach to Management that is both powerful and systematic in nature. This final component is important for landing and maintaining the outcomes achieved through the former stages and ensuring that these outcomes are long-standing. Moreover, it prevents waste of time and unnecessary efforts and helps an organisation to monitor performance against its targets and goals.

6) 8D Report Template Checklist

The 8D report template checklist is a comprehensive tool designed to document root-cause analysis using the eight disciplines of problem-solving. The 8D method involves a series of structured steps to effectively address and resolve issues that arise. Here’s an expanded explanation of each step:

1) Establish a Team: Create a multidisciplinary team specifically tasked with addressing issues and finding effective solutions. This team should include members with diverse skills and knowledge relevant to the problem at hand.

2) Define the Problem: Clearly articulate the problem before attempting to solve it. This involves gathering detailed information and evidence to understand the scope and impact of the issue.

3) Contain the Problem: Implement immediate actions to contain the problem, ensuring that it does not disrupt daily business operations. The objective is to minimise the impact and prevent the problem from escalating or causing further complications.

4) Find the Root Cause: Conduct Root Cause Analysis to identify the underlying cause of the problem. Use techniques such as the 5 Whys or Fishbone Diagram to systematically drill down to the core issue.

5) Define Corrective Measures: Develop and implement appropriate corrective actions to address the root cause. These measures should be designed to eliminate the problem and prevent its recurrence.

6) Track Progress: Monitor and document the progress of the corrective actions. Keeping a detailed record ensures that the implementation is effective and any adjustments can be made in a timely manner.

7) Establish Preventative Measures: Put in place preventative measures to avoid future occurrences of the problem. This may involve revising processes, improving training, or implementing new controls.

8) Recognise the Team:Acknowledge and reward the team’s efforts and successes in resolving the issue. Recognising the team’s hard work fosters a culture of continuous improvement and teamwork.

The goal of finalising an 8D report within eight days serves as a benchmark for timely problem resolution, though it may not always be feasible. Striving for this timeline encourages efficiency and prompt action in addressing and resolving issues

What are the Five Ps of Root Cause Analysis?

The 5 Ps of Root Cause Analysis helps identify the main cause of a problem. They are:

a) People: Human errors or actions

b) Processes: Faulty methods or workflows

c) Products: Issues with materials or design

d) Procedures: Missing or unclear guidelines

e) Policies: Rules that may create problems

What is the Common Tool Used During Root Cause Analysis?

A Fishbone Diagram (Ishikawa Diagram) is a common Root Cause Analysis tool. It visually maps possible causes of a problem into categories like People, Process, Equipment, Materials, Environment, and Management. Other tools include 5 Whys, Pareto Charts, and Fault Tree Analysis.

Conclusion

The use of various Root Cause Analysis Tools provides valuable insights and a structured approach to uncovering the root causes. Through consistent application of these set of tools, companies can develop sustainable and resilient growth models that will stand the test of time.

Learn how to identify, control and manage root cause problems with our ITIL® Certification Training.